Annabel’s Reply to the Poet
The angels you slandered surround us now
in this kingdom you thought you’d never see.
So convinced that beauty outlives death
you would rather remember my body than me.
But finally face to face, you must know
there was madness in your poetry.
If I was a child than it was not love
for I loved with a love that was mercury.
You mistook a playdate for a tryst.
It was you and your dear Annabel Lee
who entwined their destinies sitting there
by your vast kingdom, by your vast sea.
It was circumstance that I died so young,
by no means an act of jealousy
perpetrated by seraphim.
They have worthier things than Annabel Lee.
They live above, in the clouds, by God’s side,
the side where lives now both you and me.
If you ask any man if he could relate
he’ll submit, for they’ve all lost their Annabel Lees
to cholera or syphilis
or a window opened against the lee
to remind her in her sleep that yes
she lives in a kingdom by the sea.
You were partly right. The angels were stunned
to hear “a boy far younger than we,
indeed, far more foolish than we”
who could sing better than the whole starry choir.
They conspired with demons down under the sea,
whose ears were still ringing with Orpheus’s lyre,
to kill me and retire in the song of your plea.
It was not my eyes bearing down like stars.
The moon never looked a little like me.
Really it was your madness — your madness — up there
etching epics for what used to be,
portending how you were some day meant
to be heard on the other shore of the sea,
to orchestrate the sounding sea.